How to Conduct the Perfect Job Interview
Resilient Recruitment | A practical guide to preparing, conducting and following up on a face-to-face job interview.
Most managers have conducted a job interview at some point in their careers, but how many have actually received proper training in how to do it? We regularly leave one of the most important decisions a manager can make, choosing who to hire, to people who may have very little understanding of how to collect, verify and assess information about a candidate. The result is often an interview where the manager works through the CV, asks a few questions about strengths and weaknesses, and finishes by asking whether the candidate has any questions. Afterwards, the interviewers discuss how the candidate came across, whether there was good chemistry, and who gave them the best gut feeling.
I believe we should expect considerably more from a job interview. A professional interview should give the employer a stronger basis for assessing the candidate's competence and ability to succeed in the role. At the same time, the candidate should receive enough information to decide whether this is an employer and a job they genuinely want. An interview should not be a one-sided assessment where the employer asks all the questions and the candidate tries to provide the right answers. It is a conversation between two parties who both have an important decision to make, even though their roles and responsibilities are different.
Throughout my years working with recruitment, selection and interviews, I have become increasingly interested in how the interview itself affects the quality of the information we obtain. The questions we ask obviously matter, but the surroundings, the relationship between the participants and the way the conversation is managed can be just as important. A nervous candidate facing a large interview panel may create a completely different impression from the same candidate having a relaxed, professional conversation with two people. This does not mean that every candidate should be treated in exactly the same way, or that an interview should be as comfortable as possible. It means making deliberate choices that allow candidates to demonstrate their relevant competence without introducing unnecessary factors that interfere with our assessment.
This article describes how I believe a face-to-face job interview should be conducted. I use an interview lasting approximately 90 minutes as the starting point, but the principles apply whether you are recruiting an employee, a specialist or a senior leader.
A good interview starts long before the candidate arrives
Preparation begins with knowing what you are actually trying to find out. That sounds obvious, but a surprising number of managers meet candidates without a clear understanding of which competencies, experiences and personal qualities they need to investigate. The conversation then tends to follow whatever happens to come up, and candidates end up being assessed on different grounds. This becomes particularly problematic when several candidates must later be compared and the employer needs to explain why one person is considered better qualified than another.
How thoroughly and individually you prepare depends on where the candidate is in the recruitment process. If this is your first proper conversation, you may only have a CV, an application and some preliminary information. In that situation, a relatively general interview guide is a sensible starting point. It should be based on the requirements of the role and cover the themes you intend to explore with every candidate at that stage. If you have already conducted one or two interviews, however, your questions should become more tailored to the individual. You should have information that allows you to investigate particular experiences, clarify uncertainties and understand aspects of the candidate's background that require further exploration.
I believe in having a common structure, but that does not mean every candidate should receive exactly the same questions in exactly the same order. An interview guide is a tool, not a script that must be followed from beginning to end. If a candidate begins describing a difficult situation from a previous job, and that experience also tells us something interesting about decision-making under pressure, it may be entirely natural to explore that subject immediately. Interrupting a productive conversation simply because the topic appears further down the interview guide makes little sense. At the same time, the interviewer must keep track of which competency areas have been adequately covered and which still require attention. This takes practice, but in my experience it produces much better conversations than mechanically working through a list of questions.
Another important decision is who should represent the employer during the interview. My general recommendation is two people. This makes it possible to divide responsibilities, follow up on information and jointly consider where the conversation should go next. One person should have primary responsibility for leading the interview, although both can participate actively. If the interview leader lacks the technical expertise required to understand the candidate's answers, the second interviewer should ideally be someone with relevant professional knowledge. In certain recruitment processes, employee representatives or others may also participate in accordance with applicable rules, agreements or internal procedures. Their role should be clarified beforehand. Regardless of the circumstances, I recommend limiting the number of active interviewers. The more people a candidate must respond to, the harder it may become to establish an open and natural conversation.
Time also needs to be planned properly. I prefer to allocate approximately 90 minutes for a face-to-face interview, with at least 30 minutes between candidates. The actual time required will naturally depend on the position, the candidate's background and how much information has already been collected. The important thing is to allow enough time to investigate interesting issues without having to cut a valuable conversation short because the next candidate is already waiting. The interval between interviews also gives you time to secure your notes and make preliminary assessments before new impressions begin to interfere with what you have just learned.
The candidate, meanwhile, should receive clear information about when and where the interview will take place, how long it is expected to last, who will participate and what its purpose will be. If practical exercises or other assessments are planned, this should also be communicated in advance. There is no need to provide the entire interview guide, but the candidate should have a reasonable opportunity to prepare. Ask whether any practical accommodations are needed. These may concern physical accessibility or other arrangements that help the candidate participate under appropriate conditions.
The interview begins when the candidate arrives
When the candidate arrives, I believe the person leading the interview should ideally be ready to welcome them personally. It creates a poor first impression when a candidate is directed to a waiting area and left alone for ten or fifteen minutes while someone tries to locate a meeting room or gather the interview panel. You know when the person is expected, and they have taken time out of their day to visit your organization. The least you can do is be ready to receive them.
This is also where you begin building the relationship that the rest of the interview will depend on. Greet the candidate properly, make them feel welcome and ask whether they had any difficulties getting there. Offer coffee, tea or water, and spend a few minutes in natural, informal conversation before getting started. It does not need to be complicated. Asking about the journey or making a simple comment about the surroundings may be enough to get the conversation going. The purpose is not to fill the time with meaningless small talk, but to avoid making the candidate feel that the assessment begins the instant they walk through the door.
I generally recommend moving fairly quickly to the room where the interview will take place. Sometimes it may be appropriate to show the candidate a little of the workplace along the way, but this should be considered in light of their preferences and need for discretion. Many candidates are already employed and do not want others to know they are exploring new opportunities. It is easy to underestimate how uncomfortable it can be to be shown around an organization and introduced to several employees when you would actually prefer to keep your job search confidential. This deserves more attention than it usually receives, and I intend to address discretion in recruitment interviews in a separate article.
The meeting room should have been selected and prepared well before the candidate arrives. Make sure the temperature is comfortable, the lighting is good, the acoustics allow for a normal conversation and interruptions are unlikely. The room should offer appropriate privacy, and mobile phones should be on silent and preferably kept out of sight. I prefer a round table or another seating arrangement that places participants on as equal a footing as possible. When practical, I even let the candidate choose where to sit first. It is a small gesture, but it signals that the candidate is a guest who deserves respect, rather than someone being placed in front of a panel for examination.
Consider the difference between being invited to a conversation around a small, round table and being seated alone on one side of a long conference table with four employer representatives opposite you. There is already an imbalance of power in recruitment. The employer controls the process, defines the requirements and ultimately decides who receives an offer. We do not need to reinforce that imbalance through unnecessarily formal or intimidating surroundings. The candidate should be able to retain a sense of independence and dignity while participating in a conversation where it feels natural to discuss positive experiences, mistakes and situations that did not go entirely as planned.
The first few minutes establish the conditions for everything that follows
Once everyone is seated, the employer should take responsibility for opening the interview. I usually begin by thanking the candidate for taking the time to meet us. I then introduce the participants, explain their roles and outline what we intend to discuss. I also describe what we hope to achieve, approximately how long the conversation will last and what the next stages of the recruitment process may involve. The candidate should be encouraged to ask questions from the outset, and I often ask whether anything has come to mind since our last conversation or whether there is something they would particularly like to discuss.
I also try to understand how the candidate is experiencing the situation. Are they excited or nervous? Have we provided enough information beforehand? Is there anything we can do to make the conversation easier? Many people find job interviews uncomfortable, particularly if they have not been through a recruitment process for several years. We need to recognize that. If a candidate appears particularly nervous, I would rather ask whether there is anything we can do to help than simply ignore it. Some people need a little more time to settle in, while others feel more comfortable when they know exactly what to expect. There is no universal solution, which is why we should ask rather than assume.
One message I always want to communicate early is that the interview is not an examination where the candidate must guess what the employer wants to hear. We are obviously assessing competence and suitability, and some questions may be challenging. But our purpose is to understand what the candidate has experienced, how they think and what they may be able to contribute. Equally important, the candidate needs an opportunity to learn about us and decide whether this is somewhere they would want to work. In my experience, making this clear often creates a more open conversation because the candidate feels less pressure to appear perfect.
I also believe the employer should speak first. Explain what the organization does, why the position needs to be filled and what you expect from the person who takes on the role. It is useful to include something about future plans and the challenges the organization faces. This does not require a lengthy presentation, but the candidate should receive enough information to understand the connection between the position and the organization's needs. It creates a much better starting point for discussing what the candidate might contribute, while demonstrating that the employer also has a responsibility to provide information.
I am particularly concerned that we should not present an unrealistic picture of the workplace. If the department is facing a difficult restructuring process, or the position involves challenges that were not fully explained in the job advertisement, the candidate should know about them. It can be tempting to emphasize every advantage and leave the problems until after the employment contract has been signed, but that is a poor strategy if your objective is to recruit someone who will perform well and remain with the organization over time.
How to conduct the interview itself
Once the framework has been established and the candidate understands more about the organization and the position, I prefer to begin with a broad, open-ended question. I often ask how the candidate views their current professional situation and what has brought us together for this conversation. Why are they interested in this opportunity? What do they want from the next stage of their career? If they were approached through active sourcing or executive search and were not originally looking for another job, I am interested in understanding what made them agree to meet us.
This information often becomes valuable well beyond the interview itself. When I understand what matters to the candidate, I am in a much better position to explain why the opportunity might be attractive. Some people are looking for greater professional challenges, others want more responsibility, stronger development opportunities or a different working environment. The candidate may simply be curious and not yet have decided whether they want to change jobs. Our responsibility is to understand their situation rather than assume that everyone is motivated by the same things.
After this introduction, I want to hear how the candidate assesses their own competence and ability to succeed in the position, now that they have received more information about it. One question I frequently use is: "Now that you know a little more about us and what we are trying to achieve, what do you think you could contribute in this role?" It is a broad question that gives the candidate considerable freedom to identify what they believe is relevant. They may begin with their education, previous positions or practical experience with tasks similar to those we have described. I try to let them explain without unnecessary interruptions.
From there, the task is to follow up on the information that emerges while making sure we investigate the competency areas relevant to the position. I prefer broad, open-ended questions at the beginning of each topic, gradually moving towards more specific questions to understand details and clarify uncertainties. If, for example, we want to investigate how the candidate handles conflict, asking whether they are good at resolving conflicts is unlikely to produce much useful information. Most candidates will naturally say yes. I would rather ask them to describe a specific situation in which they had to manage a difficult conflict.
As the candidate tells the story, I try to understand the entire sequence of events. What was the situation? What made it difficult? How did the candidate assess what was happening, and what alternatives did they consider? What did they personally do, why did they choose that approach, and what was the outcome? We often hear statements such as "we found a solution" or "we handled the situation well". That is when we need to investigate what the candidate actually contributed and what other people did. There is a difference between having been present when something happened and having played an active role in resolving it. I am also interested in what the candidate learned and whether they would approach the situation differently today.
The same approach can be used when investigating teamwork, leadership, problem-solving, decision-making or the ability to respond to unexpected events. The follow-up questions do not need to be asked in a fixed order. The objective is to obtain enough information to understand what happened, what the candidate did and what the experience may tell us about their relevant competence.
One of the most common mistakes I see interviewers make is asking a question, receiving a fairly general answer and immediately moving on to the next item in the interview guide. They end up collecting many answers but relatively little information that can actually support an assessment. It takes both discipline and curiosity to remain with a topic long enough to understand it properly. Sometimes you need to ask for another example or return to the same event from a different angle. That is entirely reasonable, provided the questions serve a relevant purpose and the candidate understands what you are trying to clarify.
If the candidate provides information that appears inconsistent with what we already know, I first try to explore it through further questions. Perhaps we misunderstood something earlier, or perhaps the candidate is describing the situation in a way that makes the information appear contradictory. If the inconsistency remains, I might explain that I am trying to understand how the different pieces of information fit together and ask the candidate to clarify. This can be done directly and respectfully without making the conversation confrontational. Our job is not to catch the candidate out or force an admission. We are trying to establish what is accurate and whether it matters to the assessment.
A good interviewer must also learn to tolerate silence. Once you have asked a question, give the candidate time to think. Many interviewers become uncomfortable when a pause occurs, so they start explaining the question, asking another one or practically helping the candidate answer. That can interfere with the very information you are trying to obtain. Give the candidate time. It is often when people have an opportunity to reflect and complete a thought that the most interesting details emerge. If the candidate does not understand the question, you can certainly clarify or rephrase it. But do not treat every moment of silence as a problem that needs to be solved immediately.
When more than one representative of the employer is present, I want the conversation to flow as naturally as possible. The interview leader must ensure that relevant topics are covered, but that does not mean one person needs to ask every question. If the second interviewer has specialist knowledge that makes it natural to explore a particular subject in greater depth, that person can take over that part of the conversation. Both should follow the same basic approach, starting with open-ended questions and becoming more specific as necessary. They also need to pay attention to each other and avoid introducing new questions before the candidate has finished answering.
Your job is to collect information, not confirm what you already believe
It is almost impossible to conduct an interview without forming impressions of the candidate along the way. We notice how the person speaks, what they say and how the conversation develops. The problem begins when those impressions start influencing the information we collect before we have a sufficient basis for drawing conclusions.
I believe gut feeling and first impressions play far too significant a role in many recruitment processes. Some candidates immediately come across as likable, perhaps because they remind us of colleagues we already know and respect. Others may appear nervous, reserved or uncomfortable. Both reactions can influence which questions we ask, how thoroughly we follow up and how we interpret what we hear. Once we have decided that a candidate is competent, it is easy to view the rest of the interview through that positive impression. The reverse can happen just as easily.
This is related to the halo effect and our tendency to seek information that confirms opinions we have already formed. You therefore need to pay attention to your own reactions throughout the interview. If you find yourself particularly impressed by a candidate, ask what you actually know about their ability to meet the requirements of the position. If you have developed a negative impression, actively investigate whether there is information that challenges that view. Simply knowing that these biases exist is not enough. You have to make an effort to counteract them while collecting information.
The same applies to how we respond when candidates speak. We should encourage them to continue and demonstrate that we are listening, but avoid rewarding particular answers with excessive enthusiasm, approving comments or body language that clearly communicates what we want to hear. If the candidate begins to recognize which answers you prefer, they may adjust the rest of their responses accordingly. The interview then risks becoming an exercise in saying the right things rather than providing an accurate account of experience and judgment.
I am also cautious about placing too much emphasis on body language and other behavior that can be difficult to interpret. If a candidate is restless, avoids eye contact or seems uncomfortable, we do not necessarily know why. It may reflect nervousness, personality, cultural differences or something about the interview situation itself. If something appears relevant, we can explore it through conversation, but our interpretations should not replace evidence. Above all, we need to listen carefully to what the candidate actually says, ask relevant follow-up questions and document information that matters to the assessment.
Documentation should support the conversation, not interfere with it
An interview needs to be documented, but documentation should not become so dominant that it damages the relationship between the participants. I have experienced many interviews where it almost seems as though the interviewer is more concerned with writing down what the candidate says than understanding it. When you sit behind a laptop screen or write extensive notes every time the candidate says something interesting, you lose eye contact and make it more difficult to follow up naturally.
It is also worth considering how note-taking feels from the candidate's perspective. Imagine describing a difficult experience from your professional life, perhaps something you are not particularly proud of, and the interviewer suddenly begins writing intensively without explaining why. That may be enough to make you more cautious about what you share next. Documenting information also gives the interviewer a degree of control over the conversation, and we should be aware of that.
For this reason, I prefer audio recording when it can be done appropriately and lawfully. It allows us to concentrate on the candidate and the conversation while retaining the possibility of checking what was actually said afterwards. It reduces the risk of remembering incorrectly or confusing the candidate's statements with our own interpretations. It can also improve cooperation between interviewers because neither person needs to spend large parts of the conversation recording every answer manually.
Audio recording does, however, require appropriate procedures for privacy and information security. The organization must establish a valid legal basis for processing the personal data and assess whether recording is necessary and proportionate. The candidate must receive clear information before recording begins, including the purpose, who will have access, how the material will be processed and when it will be deleted. If recordings are transcribed or processed using artificial intelligence, this must also be covered by appropriate assessments and safeguards. Where the GDPR applies, the organization must comply with its requirements, and applicable local laws must also be considered. A candidate agreeing to be recorded does not automatically resolve every legal issue, particularly given the imbalance of power that may exist in recruitment.
When I introduce audio recording, I explain why I would like to use it and how it may benefit both parties. If the candidate does not want to be recorded, or we do not have appropriate procedures in place, we use notes instead. That must be a genuine and practical alternative. In those circumstances, interviewers can divide responsibility for documentation so that one person does not have to manage everything alone. The candidate should also understand why notes are being taken and have an opportunity to take their own notes during the conversation.
Remember that you also need to be an attractive employer
One mistake I believe many employers make is spending almost the entire interview assessing the candidate and very little time making themselves attractive. Sometimes it almost seems as though the candidate should be grateful simply to have been invited. That is not how recruitment works, particularly when you are trying to attract people whose competence is in demand among several employers.
If we have done a good job understanding the candidate's motivation and priorities, we are also in a much better position to provide relevant information about the organization and the role. Someone looking for greater responsibility may be particularly interested in the decisions they would be authorized to make. Another candidate may want to know more about the professional environment, development opportunities or how the employer supports learning. Flexibility matters to some people, while others value clear expectations or the opportunity to influence how work is organized.
We should use this information throughout the conversation, rather than saving our entire presentation of the organization until the end. When a candidate describes something that matters to them, we can explain how the organization actually operates in that area. At the same time, we need to be honest about limitations and challenges. The objective is not to persuade someone to accept a job that does not suit them. It is to provide a realistic picture that enables an informed decision.
Candidates should also be able to ask questions throughout the interview. If someone challenges what we have said about leadership, the working environment, expectations or business performance, we should respond with curiosity. Critical questions do not necessarily indicate a difficult candidate. They may simply demonstrate that the person takes the decision seriously and wants to understand what they would be joining.
I nevertheless recommend reserving some time towards the end specifically for the candidate's questions and any remaining issues that need clarification. This gives both parties an opportunity to address subjects that have not arisen naturally during the conversation. It may also be appropriate to discuss practical matters such as availability, working arrangements, compensation expectations or other considerations relevant to the next stage of the process.
Finish the interview as professionally as you started it
As the interview approaches its conclusion, briefly summarize what you have discussed and ask whether the candidate would like to add anything. Perhaps there is something they have not yet had an opportunity to explain or a question that arose during the conversation. This is also a useful opportunity to clarify misunderstandings before moving forward.
You should then explain what happens next in the recruitment process. Will there be further interviews, work samples or an assessment center? When should the candidate expect to hear from you? I believe we should be as specific as possible and, most importantly, keep our promises. If you tell a candidate that you will provide an update within a week, you should do so even if no decision has been made. There is nothing wrong with telling someone that the process is taking longer than expected. The problem is leaving them without information.
When the meeting is over, I prefer to accompany the candidate out in the same way that I welcomed them. We may have a little informal conversation along the way, and I thank them again for their time and effort. At the same time, I avoid giving signals about how I believe the interview went. A casual comment that someone performed exceptionally well may create expectations that are not supported by our subsequent assessment. Being friendly, professional and clear about the next steps is enough.
Before the next candidate arrives, everyone who participated should have an opportunity to secure their documentation and make individual assessments. I recommend that each interviewer first evaluates the information independently against the requirements of the position before discussing the candidate with colleagues. This reduces the risk of one person's opinion dominating the group. A simple rating scale for relevant competency areas can also make it easier to compare candidates on a more consistent basis.
We must still distinguish between what the candidate actually told us and our interpretation of that information. If the candidate was unable to describe a concrete example of people management, we can document that fact. We cannot automatically conclude that the candidate is a poor leader. They may have valuable abilities that did not come across clearly during the interview. Perhaps those capabilities will become apparent through other selection methods later in the process.
This final point is particularly important to me. The job interview is only one of several methods available when assessing candidates. Some people are excellent at talking about what they can do but perform less impressively when asked to demonstrate it. Others possess strong practical abilities but are not especially skilled at presenting themselves in an interview. Work samples, assessment centers, references and other relevant selection methods may therefore provide information that either confirms or challenges our interview findings. This is precisely why we should avoid reaching a final conclusion too early.
A good interview needs structure, but it should feel like a conversation
If I were to outline how I would organize a 90-minute face-to-face interview, I would spend the first five minutes welcoming the candidate and establishing a natural connection. I would then allocate approximately ten minutes to introductions, explaining the framework and providing an overview of the organization and the role. The next ten minutes could be used to understand the candidate's situation, motivation and background, followed by around 45 minutes exploring relevant competence, experience and specific incidents. Towards the end, I would reserve approximately 15 minutes for the candidate's questions and any remaining clarifications, finishing with five minutes to summarize the conversation and explain the next steps.
This is not a rigid timetable. Some conversations will develop differently, and that is perfectly reasonable. What matters is knowing what we are trying to achieve and keeping track of whether we are actually collecting the information we need. You can certainly keep an interview guide on the table, but ideally the candidate should feel that you are having a conversation rather than working through a form.
For me, a good job interview is one where both parties have a genuine opportunity to understand each other's competence, expectations and priorities. The employer should be thoroughly prepared and willing to ask relevant, sometimes challenging questions. The candidate should be treated with respect, given time to think and allowed to explain their experiences properly. We need to be thorough without becoming confrontational, and we need to establish trust without losing the critical distance required for a sound assessment.
A perfect job interview does not mean everything goes according to plan, that the conversation is free from discomfort, or that the candidate leaves believing they answered every question correctly. Sometimes the interview will reveal that the candidate and the employer are not a good match. That can also be a valuable outcome, provided both parties have obtained enough information to understand why.
The objective is not to find the person who performs best in a job interview. It is to identify who has the strongest potential to succeed in the job, while giving the candidate a genuine opportunity to decide whether this is the right employer.
These are the principles behind ANCHORView™, the interview methodology we have developed at TEAM NORSO. Our approach brings together preparation, relationship-building, information gathering, questioning techniques, follow-up questions, observation and assessment, with the aim of making interviews more reliable and professional.
For managers, HR professionals and recruiters who want to strengthen their interviewing skills, TEAM NORSO offers both training and certification in ANCHORView™.
If you would like to develop your own interviewing skills or ensure that managers and recruiters in your organization follow a well-designed, quality-assured approach, please contact TEAM NORSO to learn more.
Bring the ideas into your organisation.
Explore the relevant services and programmes or talk to us about your context.

